This is the ONLY church of any denomination in Shaldon which has a cemetery. St Nicholas, however, is not the parish church as this function passed from it to a much larger and more modern church, St Peters, about 1890 when Rev. Richard M. Marsh-Dunn was the incumbent at St Peters. After this the Vicar of St Nicholas has been the incumbent of St Peters.
1622 - Elezeus Coke 1633 - Phillip Smith 1711 - George Sandford 1720 - Elias Carter 1767 - Thomas Granger 1780 - Henry Manning 1809 - Thomas Westcott 1834 - Rufus Hutton B.A. 1877 - William Henry Wrenford B.A. 1890 - Richard M. Marsh-Dunn 1922 - Robert Fernsby 1945 - Wilfred Arthur E. Westall B.A. 1951 - Leonard Alfred E. Horsfield 1963 - Charles Daniel Wood M.A. 1976 - Samuel Philpott 1979 - Harvey Royden Phillips 1983 - Ashley Manhire 2001 - Geoffrey S. Richardson M.A.