| 1349 Stephen Brente | 1726 William Ford of Oxford University. Patrons being Romanists. |
| 1377 Stephen Bolestone | 1775 William Trevelyan Cox |
| 1386 Stephen Joseph | 1777 William Jenkins (Jnr) |
| 1401 Robert Julyan | 1797 William Salter |
| 1421 Robert Bury | 1848 Henry Braddell |
| 14** Walter Forde | 1849 Henry Peter Daniell |
| 1431 John Bradeforde | 1859 George Stokes |
| 1446 William Smythe | 1861 Richard Boyer |
| 1450 Ralph Thomesyne | 1864 Frederick Edward Woodcock |
| 1451 Robert Ude (Udy) | 1870 Charles Edward Archibald McComas |
| 1458 John Arundell | 1876 Edward Yarde |
| 1466 Nicholas Baron | 1892 William Yalden Thomson |
| 1473 Thomas Turpyn | 1893 Thomas Joseph Ton (or Torr) |
| 1473 Thomas Poule | 1896 Walter Champernowne |
| 1476 Elias Lymington | 1918 Richard Sydney Davies |
| 1487 John Smythe | 1922 John Thomas Collins |
| 1517 Robert Ennabell | 1926 John Pittman Harrison |
| 1532 John Boteler alias Osteler Hull | 1936 Robert Noel Douglas |
| 1547 Edward Gurgen | 1947 Harvey Thomas Hillier |
| 1558 John Genyngs | 1956 William Easton Wright |
| 1568 Henry Stephens | 1969 Harold Stamp |
| 1587 John Carpenter | 1972 John Martin |
| 1621 Joseph Hull | 1973 Frederick Herbert Gilbert |
| 1633 John Fforde | 1980 Charles Leopold Caudwell |
| 16** John Bury | 1983 William Easton Wright |
| Probably intruded by Commonwealth 1640-1660 | 1986 Nigel Timothy Schofield |
| & Undisturbed In 1662 | 1994 David Robert Winnington-Ingram |
| 1676 Richard Sparkes | 2002 Stephen John Herbert Dunwoody |
| 1700 John Edwards | 2007 Jane Jennifer Wilson |
| | |
| Notes:- |
| 1928 - With Southleigh |
| 1936 - With Southleigh & Farway |
| 1972 - With Offwell. Cotleigh and Widworthy to form the Offwell group of Parishes |
| 1985 - Northleigh became part of Colyton Team Ministry |
| 2003 - Northleigh became part of the Offwell Benefice with Cotleigh, Farway, Offwell & Widworthy. |
